Jerry Lee Lewis’s marriage to his thirteen-year-old cousin in 1957 became one of the most infamous scandals in entertainment history. It derailed a meteoric ascent and reshaped his career for decades. At the time, Lewis was one of rock and roll’s brightest stars. Especially after the explosive success of “Whole Lotta Shakin’ Goin’ On” and “Great Balls of Fire”. His wild piano-pounding style, rebellious persona, and raw Southern energy made him a rival to Elvis Presley. All of that momentum was halted almost instantly when the details of his marriage became public. Overnight, Lewis went from a dangerous symbol not of youthful rebellion, but of moral depravity.
From Babe Magnet to “Baby Snatcher”
Jerry Lee Lewis was smitten by Myra Gale Brown, his thirteen-year-old cousin, and tied the knot with her in 1957. Back then in Louisiana, where the two hailed from, such unions were not too unusual. To the extent that Lewis was worried about a potential scandal, it had to do more with the timing of the wedding, Lewis’ third, not his child bride’s age or her family relationship. Lewis had wed his cousin before the divorce from his second wife had been finalized. So there was a whiff of bigamy about the marriage. The scandal erupted during his 1958 tour of the United Kingdom, where reporters quickly discovered that Lewis’s new bride was not only his first cousin once removed but also just thirteen.
When confronted, Jerry and Myra at first attempted to obscure her age, claiming she was fifteen. The truth came out, though. In Britain at the time, rock and roll was still regarded with suspicion by social conservatives. So the marriage of rock icon Lewis came to be seen as evidence of depravity inherent in that genre. The reaction was immediate and fierce, as the British press labeled Lewis a “cradle robber” and “baby snatcher”. Concerts were cancelled, newspapers ran denunciations, called for Lewis’ deportation, and he became a figure of scandal rather than stardom. The couple fled back across at the Atlantic, but their welcome back home was not any better.
A Career Nosedive, and Comeback
The impact on Jerry Lee Lewis’s career in the United States was similarly devastating. American audiences were no strangers to flamboyant and boundary-pushing performers. However, a rock star marrying a barely teenage cousin crossed a line even for the era’s permissive entertainment culture. Radio stations pulled his records, television appearances disappeared, and promoters backed away from his tours. Within weeks, his appearance fees plummeted from tens of thousands of dollars to a few hundred. The scandal effectively ended his reign as a leading figure of early rock and roll. While Elvis, Chuck Berry, and Buddy Holly continued to define the genre, Lewis found himself pushed to the margins.
The scandal’s effects were not limited to immediate commercial damage. It also permanently reshaped Lewis’s public persona. Instead of being seen as a charismatic rebel, he became associated with a darker, more dangerous kind of notoriety. It both harmed and paradoxically sustained his later career. For years afterward, Lewis struggled for airplay and mainstream acceptance. A mythology developed around his outlaw status, however, and it began to appeal to niche audiences. By the mid-1960s, Lewis turned increasingly toward country music. His rough-edged reputation helped reposition him as an authentic, hard-living Southern musician. He began to score numerous hits on the country charts, such as “Another Place, Another Time”. That comeback rested partly on the same sense of rawness that had once nearly destroyed him.
Legacy of the Jerry Lee Lewis and Myra Gale Brown Marriage
The marriage of Jerry Lee Lewis and Myra Gale Brown lasted until 1970. It was often troubled, marked by instability, tragedy, and the pressures of fame. Myra Gale Brown later wrote candidly about the psychological and emotional costs of the relationship. She offered a perspective that complicated the public narrative. In hindsight, the scandal is widely seen as evidence of the exploitative aspects of early rock and roll culture. It also shed light on the era’s lax attitudes toward the boundaries between youth and adulthood. Lewis, for his part, maintained throughout his life that he had acted in good faith according to the norms of his upbringing. That defense, however, did little to soften public judgment.
Ultimately, the scandal of Jerry Lee Lewis marrying Myra Gale Brown was a watershed moment in entertainment history. It abruptly halted one of rock and roll’s most promising careers, and reshaped the trajectory of a legendary musician. It also left a complex legacy that continues to provoke debate. Lewis did rebound. Although he never regained the heights he had reached in the 1950s, he did achieve lasting fame in later decades. The scandal remained an indelible part of his identity, though. It remains a cautionary tale of the sometimes-unfortunate combinations of fame, culture, and the severe consequences of crossing social boundaries.
_________________
Some Sources & Further Reading
History Halls – When Frank Sinatra Was Arrested for Seduction
Lewis, Myra – Great Balls of Fire: The Uncensored Story of Jerry Lee Lewis (1982)
Ultimate Classic Rock – When Jerry Lee Lewis Married His 13-Year-Old Cousin
